| April 4, 2004, Sunday
ARTS AND LEISURE DESK
ART; A 2,000-Mile Forage for Folk Art
By DUDLEY CLENDINEN
TALLAHASSEE, Fla. -- EARLY on a gray winter Sunday morning, Jeanne Kronsnoble
and Cathy Clayton, friends and owners of different art galleries for almost 20
years, set out from Tampa, Fla., and drove north in a minivan with the middle
seat removed. The tourists were flowing south, but they were on a different mission.
They carried blankets, sheets of plywood, bubble wrap and cardboard. Maps, dogeared
address books, bottles of water, bags of chocolates. And sturdy clothes. They
would clump through damp fields and dark spidery places and sit down to midday
dinners of baked chicken, turnip greens, cornbread, peach cobbler and presweetened
iced tea. There was also a checkbook, and an envelope of cash.
For the next eight days, as I rode with them on a trip of more than 2,000
miles along the Gulf and Atlantic coasts, through major and middling cities and
small towns and down desolate back country roads, they foraged for folk art across
north Florida, Alabama and Georgia. The journey took us through towns like Niceville,
Cottondale and Hurtsboro, into poor city neighborhoods and down narrow alleyways,
out past strip malls where B. J.'s Fireworks and Tri-State Casket Sales stand
side by side, where springs, rivers and lakes are named Wakulla, Chipola and Dead
and church signs say ''Free Trip to Heaven: Details Inside.''
It was a buying trip but an emotional journey, too, among the sweet, naïve,
and dazzlingly eccentric tribe of people across the country who are driven to
make art, for reasons that often seem mystical or nostalgic. Ms. Kronsnoble and
Ms. Clayton were trying to find and buy from 13 different artists, all of whom
they knew. But some were growing old. Not all have street addresses. Or phones.
Not all who have phones answer them. In the end, they found 11, packing the van
in an intricate puzzle that grew to 150 pieces.
It is a trip the two women have made every year or two for a decade for a
joint show they mount in Tampa in the winter. For art dealers -- urban creatures,
as a rule -- it is also a trip that comes with certain hazards. ''Uuggghhhhh,''
Ms. Clayton said one day, holding her head after lunch at Betty's Bar-B-Q in Anniston,
Ala. ''If I have any more sugar and fat, I think my head will explode.''
Dealers around the country have been making similar trips at least since the
collectors Chuck and Jan Rosenak crossed America in the mid-1970's, sent by the
Museum of American Folk Art in New York to discover if there were still untrained,
naïve artists at work in the nation. Much of the professional art world thought
such primitive creation had mostly ceased as the broader culture grew more modern.
But from New Mexico to the South Bronx, the Rosenaks found hundreds of self-taught
artists, uncommissioned, unknown yet productive, guided only by faith, vision,
talent and compulsion.
In Fayette, Ala., they met Jimmy Lee Sudduth, whose palette was a bucket of
mud, fortified with molasses, colored by vegetables and plants. In north Georgia,
they found the man who came to personify folk art in appearances with Johnny Carson
on ''The Tonight Show,'' the twangy Rev. Howard Finster, who seemed equally obsessed
with God and Coca-Cola. The Reverend was chatty but strict. He wouldn't let Chuck
Rosenak buy any of his art until he had baptized him ''Brother Chuck.'' He didn't
want to offend the Lord by selling outside the faith.
Jeanne Kronsnoble discovered folk art in the north Georgia mountains near
her summer house about 15 years after the Rosenaks had been through. Now her commodious
Main Street Gallery in Clayton, Ga. -- east of Paradise Garden, the art-filled
environment Finster created around his house -- has an inventory of almost 1,000
modern primitive pieces. She knows most of the region's naïve artists. Cathy Clayton
holds their joint show at the Clayton Gallery in Tampa, where she normally shows
the work of established contemporary Florida artists. But the lust for folk art
in Tampa has grown to fever pitch. ''They're already circling,'' Ms. Clayton said,
laughing, as Ms. Kronsnoble drove through the twilight toward O. L. Samuels's
house in a Tallahassee suburb that Sunday night. ''We have people who want to
help us unload the van.''
First, however, they had to fill it. They had stopped in early afternoon at
a large fenced property on the rim road outside Tallahassee, where the woman who
signs herself Missionary Mary L. Proctor waited in flowing clothes, dark glasses,
a red turban and a smile. Part black and part white in ancestry, always ebullient
at 43, she turned her junk yard into a giant outdoor studio in 1995 after she
asked the Lord for guidance one day and the Lord said, ''Paint.'' She started
painting everything around her, including some old windows and doors, with stories
of life and faith. She became known for her painting when Tricia Collins, a dealer
from New York, happened by, bought 10 doors for about $5,000 and sold some of
them in SoHo in 1996 for $5,000 apiece.
Some days, if she prays and meditates four to six hours in the morning, Mary
Proctor said, she finds that she can make 10 or 20 pieces of art -- especially
small ones -- all in a rush. ''I don't know what I am,'' she said cheerfully.
''I just know what I believe.''
Ms. Kronsnoble smiled at her. ''Mary,'' she said. ''We need to talk a little
business.''
The dealers drove off with a window for which they paid about $1,000, and
20 lesser Mary Proctor pieces packed away so carefully that they hardly made a
dent in the van's empty space. The window would sell for $2,000, the small pieces
for as little as $100. But as Ms. Kronsnoble called ahead on her cellphone, the
good feeling turned glum. ''Mose is off the list,'' she said quietly. Mose Tolliver,
of Montgomery, Ala., whom Nancy Reagan had posed with and proclaimed her favorite
of all the black folk artists displayed at the Corcoran Gallery of Art in 1982,
had become increasingly confused and hostile in the last year. He was either 84
or 88. His family thought he had Alzheimer's. And Jimmy Lee Sudduth, who had been
hospitalized with pneumonia, wasn't getting better. He was 94. ''Jimmy Lee's too
sick,'' Ms. Kronsnoble said with a grim look, putting down the cellphone as she
drove. ''He's too sick to see us.''
''Oh, no,'' Ms. Clayton said. ''Oh, nooooo.'' For years on these trips, they
had sat in the back yard with Jimmy Lee as he painted, and on the bed with Mose,
who painted there because his legs were crippled.
''We're going to have to find some new ones, aren't we, Cathy?'' Ms. Kronsnoble
said after a moment. ''Because they're dying.''
For people drawn to folk art, the relationship to the art and artists can
be intensely sentimental, in part because the art is so personal, but also because
the artists can be so emotional. ''I love that piece,'' one of them will say.
''And I love that piece. And I really love that piece.'' Some sell things and
then try to get them back. There is also the fact that the artists are such anomalies,
so quaint and so vulnerable. They spring from a place in the culture that seems
forever vanishing.
A very few, like Woodie Long, 61, of Santa Rosa Beach, Fla., do very well.
His father, one of 18 children, was a white sharecropper in Alabama. Woodie was
a field hand and a house painter with 76 first cousins who decided to start painting
his memories for his children in 1987. He calculates that he has made 17,000 paintings
since. His wife, Dot, his business manager, controls the sales and prices -- which
range from hundreds to thousands of dollars -- with great care. Mr. Long now lives,
paints, raises vegetables and feeds migrating birds on three acres of land. He
is commonly thought to earn several hundred thousand dollars a year and supports
his fellow Alabama folk artists by buying hundreds of their works. He is enthusiastic
about the clan, which he feels part of. ''Jimmy Lee -- he's my idol,'' Mr. Long
said, standing in his studio. ''We all love each other.''
But many of the others seem to live and work alone, possessed by their visions,
oblivious to other art. Like James (Buddy) Snipe, who lives deep in east Alabama
in a sagging house with six dead cars in the yard and a ruined shed and a rusting
auctioneer's trailer from which he pulls fantastic creations made from branches,
glass and metal junk and other things he finds. (''Those are real foots on there,''
he said, pointing proudly at a peacock with convincing feet. ''Turkey foots.'')
Some, like Mr. Long, are illiterate, or semiliterate. But they live much more
precariously than he does. The art dealers and gallery owners who come to see
them may be their only sources of income, their main connections to the larger
world.
It is a relationship that begs for trust, one easily abused. All the artists
on the trip talked of dealers who took advantage of them. ''They'll come, and
they want to take your art away, and you never hear from them again,'' said Chris
Clark. He is only 45, one of the most urbane of naïve artists. He makes an array
of things out of wood, paint and cloth, including dream quilts that his grandmother
taught him to stitch, in a loft up some stairs in an old factory building in Birmingham,
Ala., behind a yellow door. Still, he took bad checks and entrusted 50 or 60 pieces
to dealers who never called or sent him money before he learned to say no.
''Now Jeanne, I've been dealing with her so long until I trust her,'' he said.
He, like Woodie Long and Mary Proctor and the others, said Ms. Kronsnoble always
pays the price she bargains for. Usually she doubles that in the gallery and New
York galleries might multiply it two to four or five times more.
But these are not easy relationships for gallery owners either. Folk artists
who are hard up sometimes use their dealers as bankers, asking for cash advances
against future work. ''You don't know what it's like to be poor,'' O. L. Samuels
said when Ms. Kronsnoble and Ms. Clayton settled into the living room of the modest
house he rents outside Tallahassee that first Sunday night.
''Oh, O. L.'' Ms. Kronsnoble said, lowering her head. ''Please don't put me
through a guilt trip.''
He is a tall, handsome black man of 72, a former prizefighter with two heart
attacks, great style and no education. He makes large, elegant, glittering pelicans,
llamas, dogs and running birds from pieces of trees. It is singular work. But
he often hocks his sculptures for $100 or $150 at a Tallahassee pawnshop, which
sells them to a local collector before the pawn tickets come due.
''People say, 'You shouldn't put your art in there,' '' Mr. Samuels said,
his voice softly musical and resigned as he moved about in the dim room. ''But
they don't know I have to pay the rent.'' He owed $650 in rent and $400 to the
power company, and he didn't have the money. Ms. Kronsnoble, who had advanced
him more than $1,000 against work that was nowhere to be seen -- pawned, probably
-- did not protest. She sat and bargained for more, because O. L. Samuels is moved
by a spirit that folk-art lovers treasure, one that makes ordinary things seem
magical and that they fear will some day disappear.
''You know,'' Mr. Samuels said, looking lovingly at the pelican he had made
that would later fetch $1,450 at the Clayton Gallery. ''I got a spirit be in me.
It be for real. The first time, it scared me. It was like a shadow in me. But
now I've gotten used to it. There is always a dot or something there -- to tell
me where to put my eye.''
Ms. Kronsnoble and Ms. Clayton looked at him. And then they gave him a check
made out to his landlord and cash to pay the bills that were due. He helped them
carry out the Pelican, the Running Bird, Happy Dog and some other pieces. They
loaded the van, gave him a hug and a tender look -- and drove into the night.
CAPTIONS: Photos: The folk art dealer Jeanne Kronsnoble,
on her annual buying trip, stopping at the Birmingham, Ala., studio of Chris Clark.;
Ms. Kronsnoble and Cathy Clayton with the artist Missionary Mary L. Proctor; below,
O. L. Samuels. (Photographs by Gary Tramontina for The New York Times)
Copyright
2003 The New York Times Company
|